How SciBite technology can facilitate gene-disease relationship extraction

As genomic sequencing technologies get more advanced, large numbers of gene-disease associations have emerged. A gene with an unclear role within a disease is a source of ambiguity and can lead to misdiagnosis. In this blog, we demonstrate how semantic search technology can facilitate Gene-Disease Relationship Extraction.

The problem

As genomic sequencing technologies get more advanced, large numbers of gene-disease associations have emerged. A gene with an unclear role within a disease is a source of ambiguity and can lead to misdiagnosis. Therefore, it highlights the urgent need for a standardized method to evaluate the evidence implicating a gene in disease and thereby determine the clinical validity of a gene-disease Relationship Extraction (RE) [1].

When we use text mining and the Natural Language Processing (NLP) algorithm to extract gene/disease pairs automatically, it is even harder to decide whether the identified pair is a real regulation or a co-incidence. As a result, we are interested in an automatic pipeline for evaluating the clinical validity of gene-disease pairs.

Gene-disease relationship extraction from unstructured text

SciBite offers a wide range of tools for transforming unstructured text into data for down-stream manipulation and analysis. For this piece of work, we used SciBite Search, which uses ontologies to semantically enrich content to enable powerful searches across multiple literature sources.

SciBite Search has a flexible query language that enables users to narrow their search results based on entities, context, and relationships. It also provides metadata that further can be utilized to enrich results. For instance, because SciBite Search has an inbuilt understanding of types of entity, we can search documents for “anything of type gene/protein” in relation to a specified indication. Furthermore, this can be limited to same-sentence co-ocurrence to gain a quick overview of likely gene-disease associations (See Figure 1).

Click on image to enlarge

Figure 1: SciBite Search Gene-Disease Relationship Extraction search query. Here we can see sentences relating to breast neoplasms in co-ocurrence with anything defined as a gene or protein.

Now we have a list of sentences that happen to mention some genes and diseases together, as shown in Figure 2. Yet, the question of “are they valid associations” needs to be addressed.

Figure 2: Sentences with (upper) and without (lower) gene-disease hits. For each sentence pairs of gene/disease (GD) formed the initial list of potential gene-disease associations (GDAs)>(HGNC1101-D001943) and (HGNC1100-D001943).

What is the role of relationship extraction?

For that purpose, we need to perform Relationship Extraction (RE). Relationship extraction is the task of extracting semantic relationships from a text.

In our case, we are interested in importing a sentence with cases of gene-disease and predicting if this cooccurrence is coincidental or describing a real relationship.

Relation extraction can be done in different ways:

Rule-based models (using language rules)
Machine-learning approach (training models based on examples)
Knowledge representation techniques (populating knowledge graphs or semantic nets)

Next step – Knowledge graph population

SciBite offers different technologies to give users various options based on their use cases. The SciBite Relationship Extraction model has been trained by our Artificial Intelligence (AI) team, and the model learns to predict gene-disease associations by observing large amounts of data.

On the other hand, knowledge representation approaches (such as Knowledge Graphs) are typically made up of datasets from various sources, which frequently differ in structure and can visualize data dependencies and interactions.

In order to populate a Knowledge Graph, we need to spot our nodes and their relationships. Each relationship can have a weight that indicates its importance. For each GDA candidate, we measure a set of metrics and give each a confidence value (weight). Later we create a knowledge graph using this information in combination with the metadata obtained from SciBite Search.

Figure 3 displays the proposed knowledge-graph schema. The schema of a graph is fundamental; If the schema has been defined correctly, countless inferences can be made based on the data.

Click on image to enlarge

Figure 3: Gene-disease knowledge graph schema. GDA represents Gene disease association nodes, which are linked to gene/protein entities (HGNCGENE), indicaitons and the source document(s) where the relationship was found.

Once the graph has been populated, it is relatively straightforward to ingest additional datasets (via ontology mappings), make changes, and scale the model. Figure 4. Shows a snapshot of the graph.

Click on image to enlarge

Figure 4: Snapshot of the Gene-disease association graph. (Green nodes: GDAs, Blue nodes: Documents, Red Nodes: Indications, Purple nodes: Genes). This allows the user to explore relationships for any given gene or indication, making it more efficient for a researcher to get an overview of current science for a given topic.

Use cases that a knowledge graph can address

In this section, we cover a few questions that can be answered in SciBite using our knowledge graphs.

For gene/disease association, those GDA nodes that have high incoming cardinality (number of mentions in documents) and high confidences have been proven to be true associations. Those nodes with lower mentions and confidence, and they are neither crowded nor sparse, have been proven to be valid as well and worth investing in as future solutions. Graph data analysis algorithms are extremely helpful in finding this type of node. Figure 5 represents the output of one of the algorithms that we use in SciBite.

We also can search the graph for the most mentioned GDAs for a specific disease as Figure 6 depicts.

Figure 5: Ranking of GDA nodes base on cardinality and confidence

Click on image to enlarge

Figure 6a: Most Involved Gene In Leukemia

Click on image to enlarge

Figure 6b: SciBite Search results.

Finally, we may be interested in figuring out which gene-diseases have the highest mentions in specific organization publications (KOL interests). Figure 7 shows the results of such queries.

Click on image to enlarge

Figure 7: Research interests of University of Colorado.

Platform independence

SciBite’s capabilities are completely agnostic to the technology used to represent or store knowledge graphs. SciBite Search, SciBite’s next-generation scientific search and analytics platform offers powerful interrogation and analysis capabilities across both structured and unstructured public data and proprietary sources.

Utilizing SciBite’s robust suite of ontologies, SciBite Search automates semantic enrichment and annotation, transforming unstructured scientific text into clean, contextualized data free from ambiguities like synonyms or cryptic data such as project codes and drug abbreviations. It supports a wealth of features, including marking-up PDF documents, support for federated searches, and natural language queries tailored to the needs of individual users.

Discover more about SciBite Search

References

[1] Strande N. T. et al., Evaluating the Clinical Validity of Gene-Disease Associations: An Evidence-Based Framework Developed by the Clinical Genome Resource. Am J Hum Genet. 2017 Jun 1;100(6):895-906. doi: 10.1016/j.ajhg.2017.04.015. Epub 2017 May 25. PMID: 28552198; PMCID: PMC5473734.

Zahra Hosseini

Senior Data Scientist, SciBite

Zahra Hosseini, Senior Data Scientist. Holds a Ph.D. in machine learning from the Science and Research University of Tehran, focusing on Natural Language Processing (NLP) and knowledge discovery. She was an Assistant professor at Azad University of Isfahan for 7 years before switching to Industry. She has been with SciBite since 2021 as a part of the data science team.

Other articles by Zahra

How SciBite and Elsevier manage KOL identification read more.
How SciBite technology can facilitate gene-disease relationship extraction read more.

Share this article